Only one who is heedless of God is alone. But if one is mindful of God, even if they are in a vast waterless and barren desert, they are not alone - God is with them.
Divine nearness and transcendence: finding signs without enclosing the mystery
God as immanent vs. transcendent reality
Editorial introduction
Only the heedless are ever alone, ‘Abdu’l-Bahá says; a traveller in a waterless desert who remembers God has company. Bahá’u’lláh goes further: God is nearer to a speck at the bottom of the seventh sea than it is to itself. Yet the same voices insist that the divine Essence lies beyond every image, that whatever a mind pictures as God is a creature of that mind, and that whoever presumes to describe Him has only stirred up dust. The sun never leaves the sky to enter the mirror, but the mirror is full of its light; a sign of God is deposited in every atom, and the person who looks inward finds one there too. Nearness, then, is met in the Manifestations of God, the mirrors in which the unapproachable becomes a face to turn toward. The Qur’an names God the Outward and the Inward in a single breath [1]. From here the way leads into the unknowability of God, the divine attributes within all things, and the realms of being that no lower order can comprehend.
Selected passages
Say: Were there to be a speck beneath a rock at the bottom of the seventh sea, God would know it and would be nearer unto it than it is unto itself. And He knoweth its secret and its intimate converse, and its beginning and its end, and its outward and its inward aspects. And He answereth it, and exalteth it, and bestoweth upon it whatsoever He willeth from His presence. Verily, He hath power over all things. This is the nearness of God, if ye be of them that believe in God.
If Thou wishest me to live,
Through me blow Thy holy breath.
The touch of Jesus Thou wilt give
To me, who've lain an age in death.
Thou, both End and Origin,
Thou without and Thou within--
From every eye Thou hidest well,
And yet in every eye dost dwell.
From eternity all things have glorified Thee, sanctified Thee, unified Thee, magnified Thee and extolled Thee. When wert Thou ever absent that nothing could behold Thee? When wert Thou ever hidden that nothing could witness Thee? Thou art the Manifest through Whose manifestation all are veiled, and Thou art the Hidden through Whose concealment all are made manifest.
Behold thou the Truth as sanctified above all things. He is manifest in all and yet sanctified above all. This is the essence of unity - that ye should behold the True One alone as all-prevailing over all things and manifest in the mirrors of all created things.
Wheresoever ye may be, verily He is with you.
Verily He, in His own Self, the Truth, hath ever encompassed all the worlds.
O my brother! The similitude of God is like the sun, and the similitude of creation is like objects. In every particle there is a radiance and brilliance from the sun. Likewise, in every mystery there is a secret, and in every horizon there is a light from that peerless Beloved and unique Essence.
And when thou observest thine own powerlessness and limitation in attaining to the knowledge of the sign that exists within thyself, thou wilt surely behold with the eye of inner and outer vision thine own impotence and that of all created things in knowing the Divine Essence and the Sun of eternal glory. The acknowledgment of powerlessness in this station, when based on insight, is the utmost limit of the knowledge of the servant and the highest attainment of the worshippers.
Truth, in its essence, hath no nearness or remoteness. It is sanctified above such stations, and its relationship to all things is on the same level. This nearness and remoteness are made manifest through Its Manifestations.
Many who wrote or visited 'Abdu'l-Baha would ask this question: God being omnipresent, why would it not be enough to concentrate on His presence in the natural world, rather than to believe in a man, a Prophet, claiming to be the intermediary between man and God?
… When Khan was in the Holy Land, 'Abdu'l-Baha made this reply to an American inquirer: There was once an Arab traveler who had lost his way in the desert. He was dying of thirst and, humbly, he begged God for water. Suddenly on the far horizon he saw an oasis with waving trees, and he knew that there could be no trees and greenery unless water was present too. When he had somehow dragged himself across the sands and reached the oasis, how did he go about quenching his thirst? Was his conviction enough for him, that growing things meant water? Or did he search avidly for a source, a crack in a rock or an opening in the earth where water could get through and he could drink and live?
We have no recourse but to turn in all matters toward that known Center, the Promised Manifestation, and the Witnessed Dawning-Place. Otherwise, we would worship an imaginary reality conceived in minds, a rejected creation, a mere fancy rather than conscious awareness in the human world - and this would be worse than idol worship, for idols at least have existence in the world of being.
Know that an Arab Bedouin asked Ali about the "Face of God" mentioned in the divine verse "Whithersoever ye turn, there is the Face of God." Ali said "Wait, I will show you through direct witness." He ordered that fire and wood be brought and lit. When the fire was fully burning in the wood, Ali asked the Bedouin, "What is the face of the fire?" The Arab replied, "It is all face, from every direction." Ali said, "We are like that - the Face of God."
Now observe the tree and the fire - through their connection and relationship, the face of the fire appears. Similarly with the Face of God: when God created the Primal Tree and created fire from that tree and connected them, it ignited and the face of the fire appeared, which is His face.
And that essence of Primal Oneness, in that most great station in which it is said: "There was God and there was naught else besides Him", is called by the names: the Hidden Treasure, the Hidden Ipseity [Huwiyyat], the Absolute Unity, Pure Essence [dhat], Absolute Non-specificity, the Hidden of the Hidden, the Primal Mystery, the Absolute Unknown, the Indescribable One, the Undiscoverable One and other Names.
… Therefore observe that although all letters and words appear from the point and all numbers from the unitary concept, neither does the primal point descend from its high station nor does the unitary concept come down from its abode of sanctity.
If thou sailest upon the sea of names, know that all are known through God, or are attributed to His servants. Everything thou seest hath been created by His Will. How then can it serve as proof of His unity? His existence itself is proof of His oneness, and the existence of all things is proof that they are His creation.
Thou art nearer than nearness itself to itself, and Thou art more glorious than glory itself in its essence. Thou art unique in the sanctification of divinity with beauty beyond beauty. O Beloved! Thou art He Who is known through all things, yet I know no one known through the knowledge of Thy Essence.
Say: Verily, women shall wear green silk and shall unitedly glorify God in the presence of those whom God hath permitted them. This is from God's command, that ye may attain unto unity. God testifieth that there is none other God but Him. Say: Verily, women shall wear red silk and shall present themselves before those whom God hath permitted them in the Book. This is of God's bounty and mercy, that ye may magnify God, your Lord, the All-Merciful, and prostrate yourselves before Him. God testifieth that there is no God but Him. Say: All the youths of Paradise, one and all, are attired in green silk, before the red, and in yellow after white. This is through God's grace and mercy, as recorded in the Mother Book, that ye may be assured of what God hath promised you in the life to come.
And the water of earthly life, compared with the life to come, is but as a dream in which ye slumber. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. Say: All hosts are present before Him. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. Say: Within His grasp are the hosts of the heavens and the earth and all that lieth between them, and all are present there. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He createth what He willeth by His command, and He, verily, is the Mighty, the Beloved. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. Say: They who purify their ears and their eyes and their hearts and their tongues and their hands, unless their hearts bear witness to that which God hath permitted in the Book - these are they who fear God.
God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. We all beseech His grace. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He originateth creation, then causeth it to return. Will ye not see? God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He will raise up creation on a Day when all shall be brought before Him. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He will surely gather you together on the Day of Resurrection. This is God's decree wherein there is no doubt. Say: All shall on that Day return unto God, thy Lord. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. Say: All shall on that Day beseech His grace. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. Say: All shall on that Day act by God's leave.
God beareth witness that there is no God but Him in the most sublime Vision and in the resplendent Horizon. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He is established upon the throne in the Most Exalted Paradise and in the resplendent Horizon. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He was not in anything, nor upon anything, nor toward anything. Such is God, your Lord, Who createth what He willeth by His command "Be," and it is! God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He hath no equal in the kingdom of the heavens and the earth and all that lieth between them, and all are submissive unto Him. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He hath no peer in the kingdom of the heavens and the earth and all that lieth between them, and all are worshippers of Him.
God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He hath no likeness in the kingdom of the heavens and the earth and all that lieth between them, and all bow down before Him. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He hath no similitude in the kingdom of the heavens and the earth and all that lieth between them, and all bow down before Him. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. He hath no associate in the kingdom of the heavens and the earth and all that lieth between them, and all are thankful for His praise. God beareth witness that there is no God but Him. None knoweth Him, and all are created by His command. God beareth witness that there is none other God but Him. None can unite with Him, and all sanctify Him by His command. God beareth witness that there is none other God but Him. None can return to Him, and all magnify Him by His command. God beareth witness that there is none other God but Him. None can bring Him into being, and all glorify Him by His command. God beareth witness that there is none other God but Him. None can praise Him, and all are strengthened by His command.
Say: God is manifest above all things, if ye would but see. Say: God is nearer than all things, if ye would but witness. Say: God is more hidden than all things, if ye would but perceive. Say: God is greater than all your descriptions. Say: God is more inaccessible than what ye deem inaccessible. Say: God cannot be remembered through anything, for all besides God is His creation, all are within His grasp, and all are His worshippers.
… Say: Even as God was aforetime and there was none beside Him save Him, so afterward there shall be none beside Him save Him - nothing can comprehend Him, while He comprehendeth all things through His command. There is no God but Him, the Mighty, the Exalted.
And in one station, all that hath been or will be mentioned returneth unto the First Mention, for the Truth, glorified and exalted be He, is an impenetrable Mystery that cannot be comprehended. In this station, He was and ever shall be sanctified beyond all mentions and names, and exalted above the understanding of all created things. The way is barred and the quest forbidden.
Say:
The essence of God is not a body like water to be contained within the body of the earthen bowl - man - a body within a body.
… If you interpret this verse according to the above explanation, it will be correct; because [it] has not left its transcendent station in order to find an entrance into the mirror, but it is ever stationed in its own center of grandeur and perpetuity.
"The sun that would come down and enter everything would not remain the sun. Its identity would be scattered."
The truth, however, is that the reality of that sanctified Essence can in no wise descend into the realm of creation. For Him there is no egress or regress, no descent or dissolution, no composition or commingling; only infinite transcendence. He is even as the sun whose rays shine upon all earthly beings. All things are invigorated and made visible by Him, and reflect His light, whilst He remaineth, in the heights of holiness, exalted above and sanctified beyond all conditions, determinations, and distinctions, even beyond the very comprehension of His creatures. Rather is it the Primal Will, which consisteth of the radiance and bounties of that Sun, that causeth the manifestation, appearance, and visibility of all beings.
Just as the sun does not communicate anything of its substance or essence to the earth, so also God does not give the world anything of His Godhood. As the sun only gives its attributes (light, warmth and power) to the earth, so also God lets His attributes shed their rays upon the world. Like the word comes forth from the speaker, the writing from the writer, the work from the creator, so the material (the thing), the spiritual (the human being), and the superspiritual (the Prophet) issues forth from and shines out of God. God works in His emanation dynamically (dispensing power).
But the Baha'is say there is God, the creatures and the medium. They state that the Reality of Divinity is Absolute Independence; if it comes within the circle of necessity, It is not Divinity; the Reality of Divinity is Absolute Perfection but the creatures are pure imperfection.
The ancient philosophers of Greece, Persia, and Egypt believed that God manifested in material things His final and supreme Reality. This supreme reality has been likened to the water of the sea, and material things to its waves. In this simile the water is considered to have two different modes of manifestation. In their form the waves are temporary, changing.
Some of the philosophers believe that God is the Supreme Reality and that every human being has a spark of this divine reality within him; that He Himself is in a state of utmost power and that all things manifest Him according to their different capacities. Therefore they hold that the Supreme Being is dispersed into infinite forms. This is the position of Plato.
… We refer to Him as Self-Existent because we need to make use of a term but we do not mean that that Being can be contained within our comprehension. What is intended is the Reality from Whom all things emanate, the Reality through Whom all things exist.
Those who claim the unity of existence are polytheists, by the testimony of existence itself, for the unity they affirm is contingent upon the existence of two, else from what station would come the negation of two and affirmation of unity? Likewise those who consider the Essence of Truth to be the cause of contingent existence.
Those who believe in causation are infidels. For causation is contingent upon the connection between cause and effect, and connection is contingent upon the existence of duality. Both stations are utterly false. Rather, the True Reality is the Essence of Truth.
Do we not see the signs and traces of God - the Unknowable, primal Cause - scattered all about us?
It is given to man to obtain knowledge, to attain to great spiritual perfection, to discover hidden truths and to manifest even the attributes of God; but still man cannot comprehend the Essence of God.
as we can only see different objects by the light of the sun, one might in one sense and with truth say the aim is in everything. In this sense also is our Lord Christ in everything.
The (Holy) Spirit is encompassing and surrounding all. It is holy. It is sanctified from attachment to a special place. It is present everywhere and at every time. It exists in all places, yet is placeless.
If this be a Book, by My life, it is verily the King of Books. If thou sayest it is man, by My beauty, it is the apple of the All-Merciful's eye, made manifest in creation. Exalted be this wondrous grace! If We declare it to be water, We behold the hearts of men consumed by it, and if We say it is fire, it hath illumined all lands with its radiant and gleaming light. Can anyone truly know it as it deserveth to be known? Nay, by the Beauty of the All-Glorious! Exalted, exalted, then more exalted, far exalted is it above the flight of the birds of the hearts of the believers to the atmosphere of its knowledge.
All the phenomena are in the process of reformation and regeneration and all the creatures are chanting the verses of oneness with their tongues of consciousness and reality.
O Educator of existence! These souls are prostrate in worship and in utmost supplication before the Kingdom of the visible world. Therefore, the hope of this servant at Your threshold is that You be their shelter and refuge.
Further quotations · supplied wording and references
The human temple that has been made the vehicle of so overpowering a Revelation must, if we be faithful to the tenets of our Faith, ever remain entirely distinguished from that 'innermost Spirit of Spirits' and 'eternal Essence of Essences' - that invisible yet rational God Who, however much we extol the divinity of His Manifestations on earth, can in no wise incarnate His infinite, His unknowable, His incorruptible and all-embracing Reality in the concrete and limited frame of a mortal being.
What is meant by personal God is a God Who is conscious of His creation, Who has a Mind, a Will, a Purpose, and not, as many scientists and materialists believe, an unconscious and determined force operating in the universe. Such conception of the Divine Being, as the Supreme and ever present Reality in the world, is not anthropomorphic, for it transcends all human limitations and forms, and does by no means attempt to define the essence of Divinity which is obviously beyond any human comprehension.
Within a compass of two hundred pages it [the Kitab-i-Iqan] proclaims unequivocally the existence and oneness of a personal God, unknowable, inaccessible, the source of all Revelation, eternal, omniscient, omnipresent and almighty...
The truth is that nobody has a route which can conduct him towards the eternal Essence. Always He subsists in His state of eternity and nothing can equal Him; nothing can come from Him, nothing is similar to His essence, and nothing separates itself from Him.
God is purely transcendent and can in no wise be defined. He is wholly sanctified above all attributes and qualities. He hath neither name nor sign. 'The way is barred and all seeking rejected.'
Concerning the Divine Spirit or Soul (Ilahiyyih), it is the Supreme Reality comprising all the divine and heavenly realities manifested by the Ancient Light. It is hidden behind the great mysteries, and it is the Point of Unity (al-nuqtatu'l-ahadiyyah) from which all things are made manifest, the Origin and end of all things, one in its essence (ahadiyyatu'l-dhat) and one in its attributes (wahidiyyatu'l-sifat).
The Prophets of God are the Mediators of God. All the Prophets and Messengers have come from One Holy Spirit and bear the Message of God, fitted to the age in which they appear. The One Light is in them and they are One with each other. But the Eternal does not become phenomenal; neither can the phenomenal become Eternal.
Now all people worship an imagination, for they have created a God in the realm of imagination and him they worship. If you ask a soul, when he is praying, who art thou worshiping? He will say, God. Which God? The God of my conception. When, in truth, what he imagines is not God. Hence, all people are worshippers of imaginations and ideals. Consequently, there is no pathway or escape for man except the Holy Manifestations, for, as we said the Essence of Divinity is pure, is holy and cannot be brought into the world of ideas. That which can be brought to ideation are the Holy and Divine Manifestations.
Any comparison is a verity emanating from the thoughts of Thy creatures. Thou art immeasurably exalted above all these and Thou art independent of that which the highest and purest minds among the distinguished of Thy chosen ones hope to attain in the apex of glory and majesty. … Thou hast, therefore, fashioned a luminous Being and an effulgent Truth, and Thou hast referred the world of creation to It and hast summoned all beings to bow down before It and hast bidden them to arrive and enter Its court. All else is verily trivial vain imaginings and hollow images. PA01513, in Makatib 1:220 and
Such is He who is too great to be named God. He is hidden, yet most manifest. He is apprehensible by thought alone, yet we can see Him with our eyes. He is bodiless, and yet has many bodies, or rather, is embodied in all bodies. There is nothing that He is not; for all things that exist are even He. For this reason all names are names of Him, because all things come from Him, their one Father; and for this reason He has no name, because He is the Father of all.
God, the blessed and only Ruler, the King of kings and Lord of lords, who alone is immortal and who lives in unapproachable light, whom no one has seen or can see. To him be honor and might forever. 1 Timothy 6:15-16
There is an Unborn, an Unoriginated, an Unmade, an Uncompounded; were there not, O mendicants, there would be no escape from the world of the born, the originated, the made, and the compounded. (Khuddaka Nikaya, Udana 8:3)
When reason is left to its own devices, it recognizes at best a God who is infinitely distant and difficult of access. Sufis accepted this point of view, but they insisted that it had to be complemented by another point of view, according to which God is 'with you wherever you are,' as the Qur'an puts it. Presence, in short, is just as important as absence; the divine immanence [tashbih] is every bit as real as the divine transcendence [tanzih]. (Chittick, intro to al-Ghazali's Mishkatu'l-Anwar, p. xii)
Meditate on what the poet hath written: "Wonder not, if my Best-Beloved be closer to me than mine own self; wonder at this, that I, despite such nearness, should still be so far from Him."... Considering what God hath revealed, that "We are closer to man than his life-vein," the poet hath, in allusion to this verse, stated that, though the revelation of my Best-Beloved hath so permeated my being that He is closer to me than my life-vein, yet, notwithstanding my certitude of its reality and my recognition of my station, I am still so far removed from Him.
Continue exploring
- God as personal vs. impersonal reality
- Word of God sanctified from time and place
- absolute freedom; independence of God
- divine attributes are within all things; every atom
- impossibility of true worship of God
- pantheism
- realms of being; three realms; five realms
- the lower is unable to comprehend the higher
- transcendence; unknowability of God
For thought and discussion
Questions to carry forward
- How does the opening assurance of companionship change the way you read declarations that God cannot be comprehended?
- What do sunlight, mirrors, speech, and the desert traveler each reveal—and leave unexplained—about divine presence?
- How do these passages distinguish the divine Essence, its signs, and the Manifestations of God?
- What questions arise when Qur’an 57:3 places outward and inward together as divine names?
- Where do the supplied Hermetic and Buddhist passages resemble the compilation’s language, and where do their purposes or claims differ?
- How might acknowledging the limits of one’s image of God influence prayer, humility, and attention to other people?