One light, successive horizons: the unity of the Manifestations
oneness or innumerability of the Manifestations of God
Editorial introduction
Attachment to the lantern, ‘Abdu’l-Bahá says, is not love of the light. The distinction separates two ways of being religious: devotion to the familiar form in which truth was last seen, and love of the truth itself wherever it next appears. Bahá’u’lláh teaches that the Prophets are one soul and one person, the same sun rising from different horizons, so that each of Them may truly claim to be the return of all who came before, and that to prefer one in honour to another is not permitted. Their unity does not erase the specific Book and mission each bears, nor does it open the divine Essence to human grasp; that Essence remains hidden while its lights shine in these mirrors. The Qur’an’s profession of faith in Abraham, Moses, Jesus and the prophets, without discrimination among them, is an older form of the same recognition [1]. The road leads on into the differences between the Manifestations and their stations of distinction, into divine unity and its degrees, and into what return can mean when the sun of today is also the sun of yesterday.
Selected passages
Therefore, whatever wondrous mentions and exalted descriptions flow from the tongue and pen refer to the Most Great Word, the Supreme Pen, the Primal Point, the true Home, and the Dawning-Place of the All-Merciful Revelation. He is the Source of unity and the Manifestation of the light of oneness and detachment. In this station, all the most beautiful names and most exalted attributes return unto Him and go not beyond Him, as it hath been said that the Unseen is sanctified beyond all mentions, and the station of the light of unity, though outwardly designated by a name and limited by bounds, is in its inner reality simple and sanctified beyond all limitations - though this simplicity is relative and comparative, not absolute in all respects.
In the station of unity, they are one reality, as it is said: "We make no distinction between any of His Messengers." Their likeness is as the sun - though its dawning-places be many, yet there is but one sun shining forth from them all. In this station, the mention of any Prophet is the mention of all; the name of Ahmad is the name of all the Prophets.
All religious laws have been detailed from a single point and ordained by God, and unto Him do they return, and there is no difference between them, if ye be of them that are certain. Despite their differences in every age and era, there is no difference among them, for they all appeared through God's command.
Fifthly: The Reality of the divine Religions is one, because the Reality is one and cannot be two. All the prophets are united in their message, and unshaken. They are like the sun; in different seasons they ascend from different rising points on the horizon.
Baha'u'llah described the Manifestations as rising-points of one Sun, meaning the Sun of Reality is one but its dawning-places and rising-points are many - that is, one Reality shining in multiple mirrors.
The Manifestation of the Essence of GOD is like unto the sun, which has different risings. The dawning-places are different, but the sun is always the same. The lamps are different but the light is one.
The essence of prophethood is one, just as the effect of one or more lights is that of one. If you want to see the light, you must look at the essence, and not be misled by the lamp through which it manifests itself. If we look at the lamps we find them different, but the light is the same. It is sent by GOD (exalted is His name). There is no difference between the prophets, because all of them are lightened from the same light, and all have attained through the Giver of the Light, but some have fallen in love with the lamp.
If we can know the sun we do not need the limitation of horizons.
Again the personality is like the chimney and the Truth is as the light. We can put the light of the lamp in another chimney and it is still the same light. We should not become attached to the chimney and put the light out of our thoughts. Consider a lover and his sweetheart. Will he love her only because of a certain costume? Nay, to appear in another garment or incognito. He must love her for herself. Even so, we must put aside the horizon, the chimney, and the costume and dispense with personality if we would know the Truth."
These Supreme Holy Souls are Godlike in their attributes. The garments in which they appear are different, but the attributes are the same. In their real intrinsic power they show forth the Perfection of God. The Reality of God in them never varies; only the garment in which the Primal Reality is clothed is different according to the time and place of their Appearance and Declaration to the world.
All the Prophets: Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Christ, Muhammad, the Bab, Baha'u'llah, are of identical stature, in Whom the same Godhead has appeared (manifested Itself) at different times as the same eternal Truth, and Who have merely adapted Themselves to the different stages of development of mankind and its capacity of understanding.
Each Manifestation was alike great in himself, each spoke with the same authority, each alike breathed the spirit of God. The same fundamental truth underlies the doctrines of each.
All the Manifestations of God bring the same Light; they only differ in degree, not in reality. The Truth is one.
All the Prophets of God were Manifestations of God. Moses, Jesus, Mohammed and the Bab were the four greatest prophets, because they reflected the Light of God in a greater degree than any of the others, and they left books to guide the people in the way of God.
Those who followed Moses accepted him as the mediator; those who followed Zoroaster accepted him as their mediator; but all the Israelites deny Zoroaster, and the Zoroastrians deny Moses. They fail to see in both the one reality. Had the Zoroastrians comprehended the reality of Zoroaster, they would have understood Moses and Jesus.
Question.- What is 'Abdu'l-Baha's teaching concerning the different Divine manifestations?
Answer. - The Reality of all is One. Truth is one. Religions are like the branches of one Tree. One branch is high, one is low and one in the centre, yet all draw their life from the one stem.
The Prophets were sent to quicken this human spirit with the divine spirit. This is the spirit that causes the unity of the human world, the spirit that bestows eternal life, the spirit that confers everlasting felicity, the spirit that enables entry into the Kingdom of God, the spirit that transforms the earthly human into a divine being, the spirit that makes the terrestrial celestial, the spirit that changes darkness into light. … All divine Manifestations, being supported by this spirit, are one; the reality of their teachings, through this spirit, is one, for the Holy Spirit is one.
The example of the Sun of Truth is like the sun in the heaven - were God to cause it to rise without limit, ye would still witness but one sun. Likewise its radiance, which is the Command of the Sun of Manifestation - in all dispensations ye witness one Command. However, Its manifestations differ, and ye magnify what appears in your own dispensation.
For all the Messengers, in their essential reality, are guides to the sovereignty of His unity and His singleness, and witnesses to the dominion of His might and His oneness. Verily He, exalted and glorified be He, cannot be known in His Essence except through what the Messengers describe from His presence.
And verily the Messengers, from the beginning that has no beginning unto the end that has no end - naught can be seen in them save His Primal Will, which God has made like unto the sun of heaven: though it rise from different dawning-places and set in different settings, it is but one and the same sun.
Know thou that its example is like unto the sun - if it should rise unto infinity, there would still be but one sun, and if it should set unto infinity, there would still be but one sun. It is He Who hath been manifest in all the Messengers, and He Who hath spoken in all the Books. He hath had no beginning, for through Him doth "the beginning" begin; and He hath had no end, for through Him doth "the end" end. It is He Who in this wondrous Cycle, which is now in its thirteen thousandth year, is known as the Point of the Bayan, and as the First Creation in the days of Adam, and as Noah in his day, and as Abraham in his day, and as Moses in his day, and as Jesus in his day, and as Muhammad the Apostle of God in His day, and the Point of the Bayan in His day, and He Whom God shall make manifest in His day, and He Whom God shall make manifest after Him Whom God shall make manifest in His day, have been known.
This is the meaning of Muhammad's word -- concerning the Prophets -- "Verily, they are I." For within all the Prophets there is one and the selfsame Cause which hath been joined to Muhammad, the Apostle of God; and from Muhammad it passed to the Primal Point; from the Primal Point to Him Whom God shall make manifest; and from Him Whom God shall make manifest to him who shall appear after Him, unto the end that hath no end.
Verily, He Who hath appeared is identical with Him Who shall appear, and He Who shall appear is identical with He Who hath appeared, just as the sun that rose yesterday is identical with the sun that shall rise tomorrow.
Rather, from the wondrous beginning of Thy creation until now, nothing hath been manifest from Thee except the sign of Thy Will, which Thou hast manifested in every Dispensation through the name of a Prophet, until the worlds attained unto the Day of Muhammad, Thy Beloved. Thou hast made its likeness before Thee as the likeness of the sun - if Thou shouldst cause it to rise countless times, it is still one sun, and if Thou shouldst cause it to set countless times, it is still one sun.
They are the Lights Who have ever been, and will continue forever to be, kneeling before the Throne of God. In each Dispensation, They are called by different Names amongst the people, and in each Revelation, Their physical names are also changed. Yet, the names of Their inmost realities, which refer unto God, and are manifest in Their hearts- without which They could not attain the presence of God by virtue of the nearness of their inmost realities-, have always existed and will continue forever to exist.
Although there are infinite names for God, yet it was through Their Names that all have received the divine effulgence.
Know thou, therefore, that I am the First Adam, and I am He unto Whom the Book was sent down, and I am He Whose law was abrogated. Likewise from the First Adam unto the Seal of the Prophets, Muhammad, peace be upon him and his family. Know thou, therefore, that I am He Who hath appeared aforetime and established that religion, and all in that day act according to My laws, yet they know not.
We have indeed heard what was decreed concerning the appearance of Muhammad, peace be upon Him and His family. There is no doubt that the appearance of the Mahdi is identical with the appearance of Muhammad in the eyes of those who look unto the Point of the Cause. Nay, it is identical with all whom God hath sent as Prophets, for all are created by God's command. This is the Origin of the Cause, which hath no beginning, unto the End that hath no end, and all stand firm through it.
And the Point of the Bayan is His Manifestation in every age and cycle - all are assured of this.
God beareth witness that there is none other God but Him, and that this is indeed 'Ali in the Most Glorious Horizon, then Muhammad in the heaven of grandeur, then the Spirit in the heaven of destiny, then He Who conversed with God in the cities of names, then the Friend in the Supreme Concourse, then Husayn in the fields of origination, then the Wronged One before God, the King, the Mighty, the Great, the All-High.
God testifies that there is no God but Him and that He Who came upon clouds of light with the name of 'Ali is His Manifestation and His sovereignty over all the worlds. He veiled His face for numbered days, then revealed Beauty once again with His Most Glorious Name.
One of the solar dawning points was Moses, another was Abraham. One of the great daysprings of the sun was His Holiness Christ. Another dawning point was Mohammed. One dawning point was the Bab, another Baha'u'llah.
And in one station We mean by the Unseen the realities of Oneness and the eternal essences who were concealed in the Manifestations of old, as ye witness and are among those who testify. In the time of Moses, the Unseen was none other than Jesus in the heaven of names, and He foretold His appearance and was hidden in His days. Likewise the Unseen in the time of the Spirit (Jesus) was Muhammad, the Messenger of God and Seal of the Prophets. Similarly the Unseen in His days was none other than 'Ali, through meeting whom the eyes of those near to God were solaced. And likewise in those days it was none other than He Whose appearance the Point of the Bayan foretold in tablets of ancient glory.
For example, consider the dot (or point); how letters and words are folded up and hidden within the essence (huwiyyat , ipseity) and reality of a dot with perfect effacement and annihilation so that no trace can be discerned of the existence of these letters and words nor is there any differentiation between them. Rather they are completely obliterated and utterly annihilated and have no existence except in the essence (dhat) of the point.
Then, when thou returnest and completeth the journey of descent and desirest to ascend unto God, the Loving Lord, make the first the last: let the portion of thy body be "Glory be to Thee, O God!"; of thy soul, "Praise be to God!"; of thy intellect, "There is no God but God!"; and of thy heart, "God is the Greatest!" Look not upon these manifestations with the gaze of difference, for such is not the path of the people of reality and the retreat of return. Verily, He Who created you is He Who provideth for you; He Who created you is He Who causeth you to die; He Who causeth you to die is He Who quickeneth you. No partner hath He in His act, nor adversary in His sovereignty.
The glory from God resteth upon the Primal Unity and upon those who bear such likeness unto that Unity that naught can be seen in them save the Primal Unity.
All these allusions are but to show the path; else, by the proof of wisdom, if a man desire to know, there is no thing but it pointeth to His knowledge; and He is exalted above being known by aught save Himself -- rather, all else is known by Him. He is, moreover, uplifted above that mention of the True One should be made in that station, for every reality is by Him made real. Its likeness is the sun: wert thou to imagine it to rise and set times without number, there would yet be but one sun.
Let Haji himself and the others look with the eye of fairness: if every day a new Truth - that is, a new Manifestation of the complete sovereignty of the One True God - were to appear, how could the divine Cause remain firm among creation? … For among the utterances of Truth are commandments and prohibitions which all need, and in essential reality the order of the world, the preservation of existence, and the unity of all on earth depend upon and are connected to these. If every day a new Authority were to appear, all these matters would become void and ineffective, and the helpless people would have to abandon all things each day and turn to a new qiblih.
They should establish beyond a shadow of doubt that by "Unity of God" is meant that the Manifestations of God Who inaugurate each Dispensation are to be regarded as one soul, unique and peerless, and all others, whether high or low, are, without exception, to be regarded as servants, utterly submissive before the Dawning-Place of God's Revelation. Even as the Commander of the Faithful, the Imam 'Ali, has stated: "I am but a servant of the servants of Muhammad."
Further quotations · supplied wording and references
And know thou that He indeed resembleth the sun. Were the risings of the sun to continue till the end that hath no end, yet there hath not been nor ever will be more than one sun.... It is this Primal Will which appeareth resplendent in every Prophet and speaketh forth in every revealed Book. It knoweth no beginning, inasmuch as the First deriveth its firstness from It; and knoweth no end, for the Last oweth its lastness unto It.
The Prophets of God are the Mediators of God. All the Prophets and Messengers have come from One Holy Spirit and bear the Message of God, fitted to the age in which they appear. The One Light is in them and they are One with each other. But the Eternal does not become phenomenal; neither can the phenomenal become Eternal.
The fundamental unity of these Messengers of God is clearly recognised, the continuity of their Revelations is affirmed, the God-given authority and correlative character of their Books is admitted, the singleness of their aims and purposes is proclaimed, the uniqueness of their influence emphasised, the ultimate reconciliation of their teachings and followers taught and anticipated. 'They all,' according to Baha'u'llah's testimony, 'abide in the same tabernacle, soar in the same heaven, are seated upon the same throne, utter the same speech, and proclaim the same Faith.'
Continue exploring
For thought and discussion
Questions to carry forward
- How does loving the light wherever it appears differ from attachment to a familiar religious form?
- What does the compilation mean by unity when each Manifestation has a particular message and historical setting?
- How does the image of the recurring sun help explain return and continuing revelation?
- How might attention to station and source status help readers consider statements about rank or difference?
- How does Qur’an 2:136 illuminate recognition of many prophets within a profession of one faith?
- What consequences might recognition of this unity have for relationships among the followers of different religions?