I manifested Myself aforetime under the name of 'Ali and took from all in the world, by His tongue, the covenant of My Self.
O people! He is My Beloved and I am His Beloved. Whatsoever appeareth from Me is His purpose preserved in tablets of glory. He spoke not except in praise of Me, and I speak not except in remembrance of Him, the Inaccessible, the Most High.
The twin Manifestations: recognition and relationship
twin Manifestations
Editorial introduction
He is My Beloved and I am His Beloved, Bahá’u’lláh says of the Báb, adding that the Báb spoke only in praise of Him and He speaks only in praise of the Báb. The bond between the two Manifestations is first of all a love, each bearing witness to the other, and only then a doctrine. ‘Abdu’l-Bahá states the doctrine plainly: the Báb is at once a Manifestation of the oneness of God and the Forerunner of Bahá’u’lláh, which unsettles any tidy division between messenger and herald. John the Baptist, calling himself a voice preparing the way, offers a familiar picture of witness and recognition, but John said he was not the Christ, and the analogy stops where the Báb’s own station begins [1]. A second distinction runs alongside and should not be confused with the first: within each Manifestation there is a station of unity, in which the voice is God’s, and a station of distinction, in which He speaks as servant. One sun appears in two mirrors, and each mirror keeps its individuality. The journey continues toward the Báb and the Primal Point, the station and claims the Báb made for Himself, and the person of Bahá’u’lláh.
Selected passages
Gate One of the Fourth Unity,
explaining that the Point hath two stations: a station in which He speaketh on the part of God; and a station in which He speaketh of that which is other than God, which latter is the station of His servitude unto the former station, wherein He worshippeth God both night and day, and singeth praise to Him both at morn and at eventide.
However, after the appearance of these holy Countenances in the world of manifestation and witness, some souls and people become afflicted with the darkness of ignorance - the fruit of their own deeds - while others become occupied with passing vanities. And since that hidden Beauty calls all people to complete detachment and sacrifice, they therefore turn away and stretch forth their hands in harm and injury.
And since these Monarchs of existence, in the world of the spirits, accepted with utmost desire and yearning all tribulations in God's path, they therefore deliver themselves into the hands of their enemies, such that whatever harm and injury they can inflict upon the bodies, limbs and members of these sanctified Essences in the realm of earth and witness, they carry out. And since the believers and loved ones are like the branches and leaves of this blessed Tree, whatever befalls the root of the Tree must surely befall its branches, twigs and leaves.
This is why in all ages such tribulations and afflictions have been and will be the portion of the lovers of the All-Glorious Beauty. There has never been a time when these Manifestations of Divine Unity appeared in the earthly realm without such tribulations, afflictions and ordeals. Though outwardly imprisoned and the victims and outcasts of the land, yet inwardly they are the recipients of God's hidden favors. And though they are deprived of physical comfort and bodily pleasures, yet they partake of spiritual comfort and the delights of the fruits of inner meaning and the holy celestial yields.
Were people to observe with the eye of insight, it would become evident that these trials and tribulations, these hardships and calamities, which have descended upon the sincere ones and the believers, are the essence of comfort and the reality of bounty, while this comfort and glory of those who have turned away from the truth is itself affliction, torment and hardship. For the consequence and fruit of these tribulations is the supreme comfort and the cause of attaining the highest horizon, while the recompense and effect of this comfort is great hardship and affliction, and the cause of descent to the nethermost depths. Therefore, at no time should one be saddened by the descent of trials and tribulations, nor should one be sorrowful and grief-stricken by the manifestation of ordained events and calamities. Rather, one must hold fast to the firm handle of patience and cleave to the strong cord of forbearance, for the Lord hath ordained a measure and reckoning for the reward of every good deed except patience, concerning which He saith: "Verily, the patient will be paid their recompense without measure."
I remember and long for Aqa Mirza Ismail with the utmost yearning and attachment. God willing, may you ever abide secure and at rest beneath the shadow of God's grace.
And verily the glory be upon the First Unity and upon them who resemble that Unity wherein naught is seen save the First Unity. Then bear thou witness that there is no harmer save God and no benefiter besides Him. This hath not been made manifest except from the Sun of Truth in all its manifestations and in its concealment, according to what hath been ordained in its manifestation.
It must be evident to thee that the divine Cause, the celestial Will, and the heavenly Purpose have never been confined by limitations. In some ages there hath been a single Soul, and in other times multiple Temples have appeared from the Dayspring of the Cause, as is recorded and evident in all the Books of old and recent times.
… And if in certain utterances of the Manifestations of the Cause and holy Dawning-places thou perceivest limitation to one, be not veiled thereby but consider the origin of the divine Tree and holy Sapling, for the Cause of God hath ever appeared and shall ever appear without limit or number.
O dear one! All nations await two Manifestations, and these two Manifestations signify the Blessed Beauty (i.e. Baha'u'llah) and His Holiness the Bab. Words are different, but the purpose is one. One has called Him "Mahdi" and another hath called Him "Christ". One hath named the Blessed Beauty (i.e. Baha'ullah) the "Lord of Hosts" and another hath called Him the "Heavenly Father".
Ye have been illumined by the guiding light of the glad tidings emanating from the morning brightness of the Bab, may my spirit be a sacrifice to His exalted holiness. And ye have received a generous portion from the effulgent rays of the loving providence of the great Luminary of the Concourse on High, the Abha Beauty Himself.
This is the Primal Point, Who circles round the Throne and proclaims with His most exalted call: "O my people! This is He Whom I gave you glad tidings of in the Books of God and what the All-Merciful revealed in the Furqan through His words 'the Day when thy Lord cometh, or some of the signs of thy Lord,' if ye be of those who know.
Say: By God! The Beauty of the First hath appeared in the Point of the Last. By God! This is thy Lord, the Most High, and whoso turneth away from Him and denieth His signs hath indeed gone astray and transgressed.
Leave behind what thou hast and take what hath been sent down unto thee from the One mighty in His Cause, Who hath appeared and proclaimed: "Verily, He appeared once by the name of 'Ali, then by this name in His final return."
Say: Verily He appeared aforetime under the name of 'Ali before Nabil, and in this Revelation under the name of Husayn before 'Ali.
Verily, He appeared by the name of Ali in the first time, then by the name of Husayn in another time.
He has come as 'Ali came from the heaven of the Cause with manifest sovereignty, and He commands you but what 'Ali commanded before.
However, O my God, since he believed in Thee through Thy First Beauty, whom Thou didst distinguish above Thy servants, making Him the Seal of Thy Prophets, the Beginning of Thy Chosen Ones, a Light in Thy lands, and a treasure and honor for Thy trusted ones - therefore Thou didst make the end of his days the beginning of Thy days, and the ultimate attainment of his maturity the attainment to the Manifestations of Thy unity and arrival in the precincts of Thy oneness.
Therefore, O my God, waft over him from the Ridvan of Thine eternity the breezes of Thy essence and the winds of Thy oneness, that he may know the mysteries of Thy uniqueness in the temples of Thy detachment and acknowledge Thy Later Beauty just as he acknowledged Thy majesty in Thy First Beauty.
Say: Verily He appeared once in the name of 'Ali, and this is His subsequent manifestation, whereat all who are in the heavens and on earth were struck with terror, save them whom God preserved through His grace, and unto Him shall all things return both in the latter and former times.
As to what thou hast asked about God thy Lord concerning what We revealed aforetime unto Muhammad in Arabic, know thou that the first one We sent with truth was Ali whom We caused to shine forth from the Persian horizon and sent down upon clouds of the Spirit from an exalted heaven, and the last one We sent was also Ali whom We named in the Supreme Concourse by Our Most Holy Name, if thou be of them that know.
The appearance of His Holiness the Primal Point, Herald of the Blessed Beauty (may my spirit be sacrificed for Him) in the dream world indicates the manifestation of lights and diffusion of signs. … And the blessed explanation in establishing the reality of the letter "Ha" between the two - this "Ha" is the "Ha" of Identity which falls between "Ba" and "Alif" and indicates that the first Manifestation is contained within the second Manifestation. The Second Manifestation represents the completion of the Word.
The Qayyum hath appeared after the Qa'im and hath arisen to the Cause with a sovereignty before which all who are in the heavens and on earth shall bow down, as attesteth the Book of God, the Mighty, the Wise.
Time and again it has flowed from the pen of 'Abdu'l-Baha and has been explicitly and conclusively declared that what is meant in the prophecies by the Lord of Hosts and the Promised Christ is the Blessed Beauty and the Exalted One [the Bab], and the beliefs of all must be centered on this explicit and conclusive text.
Abdu'l-Baha answered:
In the Book of the Zend-Avesta the Zoroastrians are awaiting the Coming of two Manifestations. Also, in the Old Testament Scriptures there is the promise of Elijah and Messiah. In the Gospel of the New Testament they are expecting the Father and the Second Coming of Christ. Likewise, in the Qur'an the Muhammadans have the promise of the Imam Mihdi and Christ.
The Reality of God in them never varies; only the garment in which the Primal Reality is clothed is different according to the time and place of their Appearance and Declaration to the world. One Day it is the garment of Abraham, then Moses, then Jesus, then Baha'u'llah.
… The Manifestations are as suns in the Heaven of the Divine Will. Sometimes the sun and moon are far apart; for instance, in the middle of month they are 180 degrees from each other. But in the beginning and end of the lunar month they are only one degree apart.
In the Qur'an Muhammad prophesied that in this Day the Sun and Moon will meet in Heaven; that is, the spiritual Sun and Moon of this Dispensation will rise together in the form of man.
This is the sincere, true, clear and evident belief of the people of the Most Glorious Kingdom and the dwellers of the Supreme Heaven: that the Universal Manifestations, who are the Primal Points, the Suns of Truth, and the Sources of divine outpourings, culminated in the Most Great Manifestation and the Ancient Beauty (may my spirit be sacrificed for His loved ones' feet).
December 1---In this greatest period there are only two manifestations, the blessed Bab (May my soul be a ransom to him!) and the Manifestation of the Blessed Perfection (Glory be to Him!).
"To remove any source of differentiation, the Believers must know that the Blessed Bab was giving the glad tidings of the coming of the Blessed Perfection, and the Blessed Perfection was the Great Manifestation.
Know thou moreover that the two calves did transgress against God in these two Names and these two most ancient Ornaments in the two most exalted Words, and they betrayed themselves in their heedlessness of these two Mysteries in this Light that hath shone forth from these two Horizons. By God! This is the Beauty manifest in these two hidden and concealed Symbols that are glorified in both worlds, and this is the Mystery veiled in the two veils.
Those denied God when He appeared with the name of 'Ali in truth, and these have denied Him when He appeared once again with this Name, at which all who are in the heavens and earth were struck with terror.
The second obligation is to establish the oneness of the invisible Beauty of Abha and the perfect divine Manifestation of the Primal Point and the pure, absolute, essential, inner, true, explicit servitude of 'Abdu'l-Baha without any trace of mention other than that.
I wrote that his highness The Supreme (Bab) was the fore-runner like John the Baptist, like the dawn. The Blessed Beauty is the sun and I am Abdul Baha and no one should go beyond that.
He gave the impression of being very modest about his own teaching, adding that the East was in a bad way, needed light, and had to be told these things. That was the reason for Bahaullah and the Bab.
So blessed are you and I, both of whom entered under the shadow of servitude to His Holiness the Herald (may my spirit be sacrificed for Him) and His Holiness the Abha Beauty (may my being be sacrificed for His luminous threshold).
O you who are steadfast in the Covenant and firm in the Testament! Give thanks to the Mighty, the Ever-Living, the Self-Subsisting Lord that from the beginning of the Cause you drank of the sealed wine and heard with your heart and soul the life-giving call of the Primal Point, His Holiness the Exalted One (may my spirit and being be sacrificed for Him), and responded with heart and soul "Yea, verily" to the call of "Am I not?" from the Abha Beauty (may my spirit be a sacrifice for His loved ones), and threaded the pearl of praise and thanksgiving to the Lord of Creation, cleansed your heart from all save the Friend, attained the presence of God, and were honored to hear His address openly.
From early youth you were assisted and confirmed, and in all occasions and circumstances you stood firm. And now too you remain firm and steadfast in the Covenant and Testament like an iron foundation, dwelling beneath the shade of the Tree of Life and protected in the impregnable fortress of the Covenant.
This is the most great gift and this is the supreme bounty. This is divine favor and this is heavenly mercy. Praise be to God, you have been and will continue to be the recipient of the favors of the Ancient Beauty from all directions.
And upon the people of Baha be the Glory.
Further quotations · supplied wording and references
...one person envisages the Unseen, the Transcendent, the Inaccessible One (God; ghayb-i-mani' la yudrak) in the Person (haykal) of the Manifestation (of God; zuhur) without making any distinction (fasl; or division) or connection (between them; wasl/union). Others there are who recognize the Person (haykal) of the Manifestation as the Appearance of God ([Himself] or theophany, zuhur'u'llah) and consider the commands and prohibitions of the Manifestation to be identical with such as originate with the One True God. These two positions (maqam) are both acceptable before the throne of God.
No distinction can be made amongst the Prophets in the sense that They all proceed from One Source, and are of One Essence. But Their stations and functions in this world are different.
There can be no doubt that the claim to the twofold station ordained for the Bab by the Almighty ... constitutes the most distinctive feature of the Baha'i Dispensation. It is a further evidence of its uniqueness, a tremendous accession to the strength, to the mysterious power and authority with which this holy cycle has been invested.
Continue exploring
For thought and discussion
Questions to carry forward
- How does mutual praise deepen your understanding of the relationship between the Báb and Bahá’u’lláh?
- What changes when the Báb is understood both as a Manifestation and as a herald?
- How do the images of sun and mirror preserve individuality within unity?
- How would you distinguish the relationship between the two Manifestations from the two stations discussed within each?
- What does John’s testimony clarify about preparation and recognition, and where does the comparison cease to fit?
- Which passage invites you to explore the writings or particular mission of either Manifestation more closely?