But you must weigh these words of mine against science and reason. If they accord with these, accept them; if not, reject them. For in the human world there is no greater gift than reason. Reason discovers the realities of things. Reason is the standard of understanding.
Science and religion: inquiry with the whole mind
harmony of science and religion
Editorial introduction
‘Abdu’l-Bahá once told an audience to weigh his own words against science and reason and to reject them if they failed the test. Few teachers have handed their listeners so sharp a knife, and the gesture says what harmony of science and religion means in his hands: not a truce between two authorities but a single reality seen from two sides, like a bird that needs both wings or two circles drawn about one centre. Religion without reason sinks into superstition; science without the heart hardens into a materialism that has learned to kill efficiently. The demand cuts both ways, and it leaves work to do. Inherited dogma must be sifted from the spiritual law it has overgrown, and a scientific fact distinguished from the theory of the hour, while the long building of a civilization in which learning and conscience grow together requires patience with unresolved questions. Emerson, insisting that thought is devout and devotion is thought, keeps that aspiration company from another tradition [1]. The road continues into the independent investigation of truth, the mind’s power of discovery, and the difference between sight and insight.
Selected passages
Until now it has been said that all religions were composed of tenets that had to be accepted, even if they seems contrary to science. Thanks be to God, that in this new cycle the admonition of Baha'u'llah is that in the search for truth man must weigh religious questions in the balance of science and reason. God has given us rational minds for this purpose, to penetrate all things, to find truth. If one renounce reason, what remains? The sacred texts? How can we understand God's commands and to what use can we put them without the balance of reason?
Religion and science are as two concentric circles that revolve around one common point, which is reality.
Fourthly: Religion and Science are inter-twined with each other and cannot be separated. These are the two wings with which humanity must fly. One wing is not enough. Every religion which does not concern itself with Science is mere tradition, and that is not the essential. Therefore science, education and civilization are most important necessities for the full religious life.
This evening, inasmuch as those who are present in this assemblage are interested especially in truth and what constitutes truth, hence my subject shall deal therewith.
Truth, or reality, is an exposition of facts as they are, - an exposition, however, which is in perfect keeping with reasonableness, with the postulates of logic.
His Holiness the Bab, and even more the Blessed Perfection Baha'u'llah, have taught that God has enabled man to recognize and investigate the laws of nature and place them at his service.
No one should for a moment believe that religion is opposed to science and reason. That science which contradicts true religion is no science, and that religion which teaches contrary to what science and reason teach is no religion.
Religion must be reasonable; it must agree perfectly with science, so that science shall sanction religion and religion sanction science. The two must be brought together, indissolubly, in reality.
They must correspond religious ideals with the deductions of science and reason and discard all such theories which cannot stand the test of intellect and empirical knowledge.
The fourth principle declares that religion must be in conformity to science and reason. If a religion does not agree with the postulates of science nor accord with the regulations of reason it is a bundle of superstitions; a phantasm of the brain. Science and religion are realities, and if that religion to which we adhere be a reality it must needs conform to the fundamental reality of all things.
Fourth, religion must accord with science and sound reason, for if it conflicts with these it is but superstition, since science is reality. If any religious matter conflicts with science and reason, it is superstition. True science is light, and what opposes it must be darkness. Therefore, religion, science and reason must be in harmony.
Furthermore, Baha'u'llah proclaimed that religion and science are twins, inseparable from each other. A religion that does not conform with reason, science and knowledge is but the traditions of forefathers and vain imaginings, for science is an expression of truth. Therefore religion must accord with science, and if it does not, it is vain imagining and false.
His fourth teaching is that religion and science are twins. If religion opposes science, it is ignorance. Therefore, all religious matters must conform to science, for that which contradicts science is ignorance.
Thus for the first time religion will become harmonized with science and science will be the hand-maid of religion, both showering their material and spiritual gifts on all humanity.
Thus ... religion will become harmonized with science, and science will be the handmaid of religion, both showering their material and spiritual gifts on all humanity.
And likewise about scientific matters, about historical matters, about the existing arts, because in this Cause science and religion are twins.
Yes, the things which are contrary to spirituality are those that oppose true science and a sound mind."
Q. How can we compare philosophical thoughts with religious thoughts?
A. Know that this nether world is the mirror of the kingdom, and the former is exactly the counterpart of the latter. The sound opinions of the world, which are the results of philosophical right thinking, correspond to the Traces of the Kingdom, and there does not exist any difference whatever between them.
Among Baha'u'llah's teachings is that religion must accord with science and reason, for if it conflicts, it is mere imitation and the wise and knowing cannot accept it.
Among them is the reconciliation of science, reason and religion.
And among the teachings is that religion must conform to science and reason, not be superstitions that reason can in no way verify.
Another teaching declares the conformity of religion with reason; whatever religion prescribes, a sound reason must approve.
Fourth is that religion must conform with reason and science, otherwise it is superstition.
Fourth, science and religion must walk hand in hand.
Science and religion will embrace each other.
A religion which does not conform with the postulates of science is merely superstition.
Fourth, the comparison of religion with science with a view of conforming the religious principles with scientific postulates.
Commenting on this, He declared that the religion which is not in conformity with science should not be considered religion at all.
4 - Religion has to be in concord with science and reason. When religion is not in concord with reason, it does not satisfy our conscience.
The fourth teaching of Baha'u'llah is that religion must accord with reason. If religion be contrary to reason, it is superstition.
But science and reason are light - religion must accord with science and reason. A religion that does not accord with universal science and reason is ignorance. We say science and ignorance are light and darkness. If religion opposes science, that is ignorance. Therefore religion must accord with reason and science.
… The greatest bounty of God to man is knowledge, and man's distinction from animals is through reason. So if religious beliefs contradict science and reason, they are assuredly ignorance.
For example, the first weapon of the opponents was this: "Whatever is contrary to science is ignorance." We proclaimed that religion is in accord with science, and that the two are one; and that every question among the questions of religion which is not in conformity with science is vain imagination. Thus did we break this weapon of theirs. For they desire to say that religion is contrary to science and reason, and therefore is ignorance.
Know that this material world is the mirror of the Kingdom, and each of these worlds is in complete correspondence with the other. The correct theories of this world which are the result of sound scientific thinking are in agreement with the divine verses without the slightest divergence between them, for the truth of all things is laid away in the treasuries of the Kingdom. … If a scientific theory does not correspond with [the intent of] the divine verses, it is certain that it is the essence of error.
Thus in the Qur'an verses were explicitly revealed that contradicted the philosophical views, technical matters and mathematical principles of the learned of that age. Therefore it was thought that these divine texts were contrary to reality since they opposed the established mathematical technical principles of the horizons. At that time, all mathematical matters were based on Ptolemaic principles, and the Almagest was accepted by all people of learning in all climes.
"If the churches" he said "are anxious to win the souls back to Christ they must interpret these 'seven great mysteries' of Christianity according to science and reason - otherwise no liberal-minded person will ever accept the old, hide-bound interpretations."
The Master spoke to a bishop, saying, 'My hope is that you will abandon harmful imitations, spread the truth of the teachings of Christ and remove all those dogmas that are against science and reality.'
One of the chief reasons for this growing apathy is that the ministers of religion have taught that religion is opposed to science and reason and have thus enforced imitation. You must, therefore, relate religious verities to science.
Today, the greatest and speediest remedy and the sole effective antidote that the Divine Physician has prescribed for the world's ills is the oneness of humanity, universal peace, the explanation of the principles of the divine religions and the removal of dogmatic imitations and customs which are contrary to science and reason.
… Thus Baha'u'llah has said, 'Every matter that is contrary to sound reason and science and is opposed to the fundamental principles of the divine religions is an obstacle to progress and a cause of people avoiding and rejecting the laws of God.'
"People have a superstitious respect for certain doctrines which are against science and the wise men of the country have thought that religion is opposed to science. Know thou that the great ethical foundation of knowledge is divine revelation and the basis of religion is reality itself.
O thou who art thoughtful about the Kingdom of existence! The foolish ones gazed at the realm of existence, the plane of Nasut, and desired keen sight, and searched and discussed and sought to uncover the mysteries of being, and wished to discover the secrets of creation, and yearned for knowledge of the metaphysical realm. Alas, alas! What madness is this, what imagining of fancy and conjecture! And stranger still that they counted these conjectures as sciences and this madness as wisdom from the peerless world.
The foundations of divine religion do not negate sound reason and true science. The principles of divine religion do not contradict knowledge and insight, except for some principles and minutiae of the law which were given according to the exigencies of the time and age.
All His teachings and laws are in keeping with the spirit of this age and the needs of the people. And greatest of all is the abandonment of religious superstitions and dogmas and the conformity of spiritual matters with scientific and rational arguments.
Illumination of science has advanced, likewise religion must advance.
Even the material sciences and crafts have reached a level that a child is better informed than the philosophers of the past. Behold, for instance, how a child is more skilful than Euclid in mathematics and algebra; for this science hath advanced through the passage of ages and centuries, it hath been refined, condensed, discoveries made, until it hath reached the stage of maturity.
When the Children of Israel taught both material and religious sciences together in their schools, this resulted in the education of skilled individuals. However, later among the followers of religions, especially among Muslims, education in schools became limited to religious issues and discussions, and even that ended up being confined to debates about words.
Praise be to God, this is the age of the discovery of the realities of things.
Verily I say unto you, this age is the age of science. This age is the age of the appearance of the truth.
For this Century is the Century of light; the Cycle is the Cycle of science; this period is the period of reality.
We hope that the future generations of humanity will become freed from these imaginations and superstitions and will walk on the terra firma of scientific certainty and spiritual truths....
Thou art investigating reality and bringing matters into conformity with science and reason.
Science is systematized Truth. The laws of spiritual science are as exact as those of mathematics. Every hour of positive high affirmation of the ideal perfection of mind and body, tends directly to actualize such conditions.
In the world of existence physical things have a connection with spiritual realities. One of these things is the voice, which connects itself with the spirit; and the spirit can be uplifted by this means -- for though it is a physical thing, it is one of the material, natural organizations -- therefore, it is effective.
Conversely, the material mind finds various nourishments and progresses through wonderful scientific discoveries.
… So if you want to have lofty aspirations, you must set the heart in motion to unite with knowledge - that is, to join spiritual virtues with physical perfections.
Morality is the basis of the happiness of the world of humanity. Merciful attributes are the best adornments of man. Science holds the next position to morality. … If a nation be well qualified with education and yet dispossessed of good morals, it will not attain happiness. If that same nation be dispossessed of education, but possessed of moral training, it will be capable of accomplishing philanthropic deeds. When Morality and science go hand in hand, then will it be light upon light.
"Praise be to God, that stupendous material developments are obtained in this country; but material civilization alone does not safeguard the progress of a nation, because through material civilization dynamite, Krupp guns, projectiles and Mauser rifles are invented: thus the infernal instruments of human fratricide are multiplied and constantly perfected.
… "When material civilization joins hands with spiritual civilization, then it will be perfect.
[To those who were present he speaks about science and religion; that religion must ever become the cause of amity and love, otherwise irreligion is better; and science at the same time must be the means of human progress and enlightenment. If science creates deadly weapons for human slaughter and destruction it is worse than ignorance.]
Similarly, I announce: Religion must be the promoter of science and civilization. Otherwise, its absence is preferable.
If religion be the cause of enmity, he declared, its absence is better than its presence, for the purpose of religion is love of mankind, and if religion yields enmity surely its non-existence is preferable. Thirdly, Baha'Ullah proclaimed that religion must correspond with science, for religion is reality and science is reality, and reality corresponds. It is not multiple, there is no difference in any reality. If a religious question be opposed to reason and science, it is pure imagination and baseless, for the opposite of knowledge or science is ignorance.
Furthermore, Baha'u'llah proclaimed that religion should be the cause of love and enlightenment in the world, the cause of unity of the human race. If it becomes the cause of strife and bloodshed and savagery, irreligion is better, for God established religion for unity, not hatred - for connection between people, not estrangement. He also stated that religion must accord with science and reason; if it does not, it is mere superstition.
The world of matter will become the expression of the world of mind. Then discoveries will be revealed, inventions will multiply, the sciences advance by leaps and bounds, the scientific culture of the earth will develop along broader lines. Then the nations will be enabled to utilize the latest and best thought, because expressed in the International Language.
The seventh teaching of Baha'u'llah concerns itself and is in accord with this system of universal education; it is that all the children should study and acquire a profession, that there should not remain a single individual without a profession whereby he can earn his livelihood. Baha'u'llah further declares that through the equipment of science and art the misunderstandings which have prevailed between religion and science will become reconciled.
The first is investigation of truth,
The second, the oneness of mankind,
The third, universal peace,
The fourth, conformity between science and divine revelation,
First is the independent investigation of truth, second is the oneness of humanity, third is that religion must be the cause of love and fellowship - if it is not the cause of love and fellowship it has no purpose, fourth is that religion must accord with science, fifth that religious prejudice, sectarian prejudice, racial prejudice and national prejudice destroy the foundation of humanity - all people are God's sheep and of one race and the earth is one homeland, sixth that one must be free of all imitations and hold fast to the foundation of divine religions, seventh is unity of language - one language must be chosen or newly invented that will be universal so that misunderstandings between religions and races and nations will disappear, and likewise the equality of men and women, and likewise the spread of sciences and knowledge, and likewise the union of women and men among all religions and nations, and likewise justice and equity, and likewise political unity and so forth.
My message is the oneness of humanity and universal peace; the harmony of true science and religion; the equality of rights; the elimination of religious, racial and political prejudices; the truth of all the divine religions; the removal of religious imitations and superstitions; the education of women to such a degree that they may have equal rights with men; the adjustment of the economic condition of all people so that if a rich man enjoys honor and affluence, the poor man may also have a mat to lie on and a house to dwell in; the establishment of spiritual civilization; the reformation of human morals; the unity of all religions, so that when the people of the world recognize the truth of all religions, they may become united since truth is one - if they follow imitation, war and dissension shall remain, because imitations are the cause of differences.
This matter has now become evident to all that all the teachings of Baha'u'llah conform with science and reason - no one can deny it.
Similarly, he speaks with rational proofs and arguments about the oneness of humanity, the harmony of religion with reason and science, the promotion of universal peace, East-West relations, the falsity of religious prejudice, the censure of national and racial prejudice, the reproach of political prejudice, equality of rights between men and women, advancement of true sciences and knowledge, reconciliation between natural and divine philosophy, and the spirituality of the human world.
My objects are the establishment of the Cause of international arbitration, the promotion of the oneness of the world of humanity, the conformity of religion with science and reason, the elucidation of the essential unity of the divine religions, the explanation of the continuity of the prophetic revelation, the instruction of mankind in the knowledge of human brotherhood, the inculcation of the primordial oneness of all phenomena, the upraising of the standard of the solidarity of the human race, the creation of a nucleus for bringing about the universal race, the spread of the precepts of spiritual civilization, the teachings of the synthesis of the heavenly philosophy, the readjustment of the economic relations between the capitalists and laborers, so that each individual member of the world of humanity may enjoy the utmost welfare and prosperity, the organization of the Arbitral Court of justice - in order that all the nations of the world may settle before that Court their international disputes and thus remove all the traces of enmity and hatred and the upholding of the principle of one auxiliary, universal language.
Therefore when this Cause is fully spread in Europe, warfare will be the thing of the past, universal Peace will be realized, the oneness of the world of humanity will be practiced, religion and science will work hand in hand.
The third principle He gave us is the harmony of science and religion. Both science and religion are truth. If religion is against reality and truth it is mere superstition. Every religious tenet that conflicts with true knowledge and sound reasoning is not worthy of belief.
Religion will accord with science and promote peace and harmony.
We hope that the friends of God and handmaidens of the Merciful will, in accordance with heavenly teachings, serve the unity of the human world, consider religion as the foundation of love and fellowship among humanity, and strive to reconcile religion and science.
I desire that all of you may speak on the material and divine sciences with clear and convincing words.
Further quotations · supplied wording and references
Religion and reason are the same; they cannot be separated from each other.
Science and religion are light; religion must be in harmony with science and reason.
...if religious principles do not accord with science and reason, they do not inspire the heart with confidence and assurance.
...there is a basic distinction between scientific fact and reasoning on the one hand and the conclusions or theories of scientists on the other. There is, and can be, no conflict between true religion and true science...
...the principle of harmony of science and religion means not only that religious teachings should be studied in the light of reason and evidence as well as of faith and inspiration, but also that everything in creation, all aspects of human life and knowledge, should be studied in the light of revelation as well as in that of purely rational investigation.
"Knowledge is one point, which the foolish have multiplied". [Hadith]
Know then that those mathematical [astronomical] questions which have stood the test of scrutiny and about the soundness of which there is no doubt are those that are supported by incontrovertible and logically binding proofs and by the rules of geometry as applied to astronomy; that are based on observations of the stars and careful astronomical research, and are in conformity with the principles of the universal themes expounded in the divine sciences. ('Abdu'l-Baha, provisional translation, Lawh-i-Aflakiyyih,
The Revelation proclaimed by Baha'u'llah, His followers believe, is divine in origin, all-embracing in scope, broad in its outlook, scientific in its method...
There is, and can be, no conflict between true religion and true science: true religion is revealed by God, while it is through true science that the mind of man "discovers the realities of things and becomes cognizant of their peculiarities and effects, and of the qualities and properties of beings" and "comprehendeth the abstract by the aid of the concrete".
It has become customary in the West to think of science and religion as occupying two distinct -- and even opposed -- areas of human thought and activity. This dichotomy can be characterized in the pairs of antitheses: faith and reason; value and fact. It is a dichotomy which is foreign to Baha'i thought and should be regarded with suspicion by Baha'i scholars in every field. The principle of the harmony of religion and science means not only that religious teachings should be studied in the light of reason and evidence as well as of faith and inspiration, but also that everything in creation, all aspects of human life and knowledge, should be studied in the light of revelation as well as of purely rational investigation.
The insights and skills generated by scientific advance will have always to look to the guidance of spiritual and moral commitment to ensure their appropriate application; religious convictions, no matter how cherished they may be, must submit, willingly and gratefully, to impartial testing by scientific methods.
The prosecution of this vast enterprise will depend on a progressive interaction between the truths and principles of religion and the discoveries and insights of scientific inquiry. This entails living with ambiguities as a natural and inescapable feature of the process of exploring reality. It also requires us not to limit science to any particular school of thought or methodological approach postulated in the course of its development.
...the principle of harmony between religion and science, while it enables us, with the help of reason, to see through the falsity of superstitions, does not imply that truth is limited to what can be explained by current scientific concepts. Not only do all religions have their miracles and mysteries, but religion itself, and certain fundamental religious concepts, such as the nature of the Manifestations of God, are far from being explicable by present-day scientific theories.
Love is as much its demand, as perception. Indeed, neither can be perfect without the other. In the uttermost meaning of the words, thought is devout, and devotion is thought. … But when a faithful thinker, resolute to detach every object from personal relations, and see it in the light of thought, shall, at the same time, kindle science with the fire of the holiest affections, then will God go forth anew into the creation.
The unfortunate effect of this is that science has drifted apart from religion, and religion has become a mere blind and more or less apathetic following of the precepts of certain religious teachers, who insist on their own favourite dogmas being accepted even when they are contrary to science. This is foolishness, for it is quite evident that science is the light, and, being so, religion truly so-called does not oppose knowledge. … But the religion which does not walk hand in hand with science is itself in the darkness of superstition and ignorance. Much of the discord and disunion of the world is created by these man-made oppositions and contradictions. If religion were in harmony with science and they walked together, much of the hatred and bitterness now bringing misery to the human race would be at an end.
...as we are a religion and not qualified to pass on scientific matters we cannot sponsor different treatments.
Continue exploring
- four methods of acquiring knowledge
- independent investigation of truth; reality
- lists; enumerations of Baha'i principles
- progress and the continual ascent of material civilization
- relativity and complementary truths
- religion as reality; definitions of religion
- the mind's power of discovery
- two kinds of knowledge [ilm and irfan]; sight and insight
For thought and discussion
Questions to carry forward
- How does the invitation to test the speaker’s own words affect your understanding of faith and independent investigation?
- What do the images of two wings, twins, and a common center reveal, and where might these images leave questions unanswered?
- How might a reader distinguish a religious teaching from an inherited interpretation, and scientific evidence from a provisional theory?
- What do the passages suggest about the moral responsibilities that accompany scientific discovery?
- Where does Emerson’s account of thought and devotion illuminate this compilation, and where do his assumptions call for further examination?
- How could a community practice both conviction and openness while living with unresolved questions?