Justice and mercy: protecting rights, opening a future
justice and mercy
Editorial introduction
A labourer who has worked from morning till evening is owed his wage; that is justice. To reward him when he has done nothing is bounty. ‘Abdu’l-Bahá’s homely example opens a subject that soon becomes demanding, because the two responses to human need pull in different directions and a life needs both. If someone wrongs you personally, you are to forgive; if they wrong everyone, their victims’ rights are not yours to give away, and the social body must rise to protect. No one may take vengeance, yet reward and punishment remain the two pillars of world order. Kindness shown to the tyrant or the thief only confirms them in their ways, while a government that saves predators from their own nature consoles the oppressed. Rulers and judges who remember that they will reap what they sow find their judgments growing just. Micah folds the whole matter into one summons, to do justly, love mercy and walk humbly with God [1], and humility is the right ending, since whoever prays for bounty rather than strict deserts learns how to extend it. From here the path leads to forgiveness and grace, to social and divine justice, and to reward and punishment.
Selected passages
O sign of bounty! The favors of the Sovereign of existence which are given according to merit - which means giving each rightful one their due - fall under the requirements of justice. However, the Most Great Guidance is a supreme gift and pertains to grace and bounty.
Do not look to lack of capacity, but consider bounty alone as the measure. Beseech His Holiness the One God for grace, that He may open the gate of bounty and not decree justice. For justice is giving each their due right, and if matters proceeded thus it would become difficult and complicated.
The justice and mercy of God is very difficult a subject and requires much reflection upon our Lord's words. First to know the meaning of justice. It is not equality, but the giving to everyone according to his right. But it isn't that one deals with a learned man in the same way with an enemy and friend is not Justice, nor to deal with animal and man in the same way. The meaning of Justice is to give what is due to each one--to deal differently with the learned and ignorant.
God possesses the attributes of both justice and mercy. Justice demands that bounty be given to all equally, while Mercy gives bounty without regard to merits or deserts, upon whomsoever God wishes.
If the creatures act according to the Commandments, this has nothing to do with Mercy, but is Obedience.
For illustration, a man called Sheikh Mohammed Hassan was made to attain the Gift, therefore the station of the Bounty and Mercy is altogether different from that of Justice. If a person does everything in Heaven and earth, he may not be fitted to receive the Gift of GOD.
If someone transgresses against you personally, you should forgive them. But if they transgress against everyone, you cannot forgive everyone's right. Therefore the social body must rise up to defend and protect.
Man, as an individual unit of human society must not base his deeds upon the law of retaliation. He must forgive, just as God forgives the sins and transgressions of his servants.
Although people have no right to exact vengeance, reward and punishment must be carried out, for these are the two pillars upon which the canopy of world order rests.
O servant of God! Your letter was received. In truth, undertaking that matter oneself was not permissible. However, the government has the right to carry out retribution through other means apart from the heir.
Nevertheless, supplications and entreaties were made at the threshold of divine grace and favors, that pardon and forgiveness might encompass all and endless bounties might surround them.
But consider the future: if a just government arises as it should to establish justice and equity, saving the predators from their predatory nature and consoling the oppressed, it will become the cause of success and prosperity and be confirmed in salvation and deliverance. We do not seek revenge nor are we content with anyone's punishment and torment. However, if severe retribution is not enacted, wolves will continually test their claws in the blood of God's sheep and will not rest for a moment except to stain their teeth and claws with pure blood.
Let the friends of God be the source of moderation and restraint, therefore; let them be the source of mercy and generosity to others. My hope is that they may illumine this dark world and show kindness to all its peoples, that they will treat the stranger as a friend and the deprived one as an intimate companion, that they will be compassionate towards the ignorant and offer guidance to the aggressor in such wise he may acquire angelic qualities, be free from violence, transform these instincts of cruelty to those of trust, adopt the characteristics of the meek and accept the way of these exiles.
Chastisement however, if happens according to divine law in absolute fairness and justice will be rewarding and the cause of good. Because in doing such, that person has executed the divine ordinances and not one's selfish desires.
O distinguished person! People are weak and deceitful, helpless and crafty. They must be held through fear and hope - that is, no soul should despair of forgiveness for mistakes, yet should fear committing sin and rebellion, so that if they fall short they may have hope of forgiveness, and if thoughts of corruption and sedition cross their minds they may fear being called to account.
A father or a teacher sometimes rewards children and sometimes punishes them. The purpose of his punishment is to train his children and is actually a form of mercy and kindness unto them. Although it appears as wrath yet in reality it is compassion. If it appears on the surface to involve hurt and pain inwardly it is sweet and refreshing water.
For the kings of the world there has not been and is not any helper mightier than justice and wisdom. Some time ago this utterance was recorded by the Pen of truth in a heavenly letter in the Arabic tongue: "O concourse of rulers! There is no force in the world mightier than justice and wisdom. Blessed is the king before whose face marcheth the standard of wisdom and behind whom standeth the host of justice.
O friend! The pavilion of the world's tranquility is upheld by these two pillars: justice and wisdom.
He can treat with fairness and justice his subjects or deal with them in the spirit of a tyrant. But the King has given him the laws whereby to guide himself in all his dealings with the people fairly and equatably and not commit injustice.
The House of Justice will decide between kings and kings. All judgment will be from the standpoint of God's Laws. Then rich and poor will be alike justly treated.
The effort made for justice is real and in this country the law is the same for the poor as for the rich.
5. The Blessed Perfection Baha'u'llah further said in the Tablet of Ishraqat: "Reward and punishment are the basic pillars of the world". Thus the Houses of Justice, in addition to their administrative tasks, also have to act in a judicial capacity. Equally important is the setting-up and supervision of a school system and the just care of the poor, and social welfare.
The happiness of humanity lies rather in recognized justice, love of virtue, and in giving every class of creation its due right. For divine creation varies in degrees of intelligence, capacity and perception. How then can equality be possible? And how can rewards and recompense be abolished? These are two principles that distinguish between people, and it is not possible to eliminate compensation which leads to advancement, nor punishment which casts down to the lowest depths.
Whatever skilled physicians and surgeons do regarding a patient is valid and executable, but they must be adorned with the ornament of justice. If they know the truth, this is assuredly preferable and more beloved.
As to what thou didst write regarding the property at the door of the house which is with the peasants, that whatever they have should be taken, whether livestock or other things that may exist - after this matter was presented He said: "O Ali, fix thy gaze upon the horizon of justice and fairness. Action must not depart from mercy and loving-kindness.
Therefore, the government must act according to heavenly teachings, become a true shepherd and show kindness to its subjects. When this occurs, the Word of God will guarantee the continuance of sovereignty in that family and dynasty, and through the passing of centuries and ages, no harm shall ever befall it.
May God grant success. We hope that soon a just government will be established and both great and humble will find comfort and ease.
The new melody of the Concourse on High has reached all corners and regions, and God willing, it will raise the banner of justice and equity through the proclamation of human oneness and universal fellowship, and will demolish the foundation of tyranny and oppression.
The government itself, praise be to God, is just and generous, but the troublemakers do not rest and commit oppression against the faithful ones.
It is hoped the new government will successfully establish justice and fairness such that they may discipline the rebellious and seditious ones.
Praise be to God that the secret instigator of this affair has received the recompense for his deeds, and it is hoped that a just government will arise to deal with equity and fairness and become a manifestation of the All-Merciful, the Compassionate.
They ruled their subjects according to their whims nor did they listen to the injunctions of their sovereign father.
Asked if it were ever right to rebel against an earthly ruler, He replied:
"Yes, if he deals unjustly and tyranically with his people he forfeits the right to govern them."
Because peoples and nations did not act in accordance with justice, and tyrannized innocent men, this war had to sweep away all remnants of autocracy, absolutism and militarism, and usher in an era of democracy, equality before the law, and international peace.
Let us be friends and comrades and not as warring enemies. I invite you and all your army to be my guests for a few months. We will spread the feasts of joy and merry making and consort with each other with perfect intimacy. Our men instead of killing each other will live side by side. Is not this better than the grim battlefield strewn with dead and wounded?"
As to the fifth verse: When all these brutalities are committed, when governments and nations have had enough carnage, bloodshed, destruction, then the Balances of Divine Justice will be set up. Those souls who have been kind and merciful, who have promoted peace and good-fellowship, who have joined the rank of the army of the Kingdom or in other words those "whose balances are heavy" that is; his good deeds outweigh his evil deeds - he shall attain to the good-pleasure of the Lord and receive not only the approbation of all mankind but of his Creator who watches over all things and who loveth a faithful steward.
Justice and fairness have vanished from the world and the oppressors of the age are ablaze with the fire of greed and passion.
Today is the day of helplessness and supplication, for the oppressors of the earth have surrounded from all directions the party that is associated with the Truth. This fire of oppression will not be extinguished save through the power of God, exalted be His glory. The people of truth must beseech Him at all times that the restraining veils may be rent asunder through divine power and the sun of justice and righteousness may illumine the world.
Until now His Majesty the King hath not become aware of the good intent of this Wronged One, though the people of God are well aware of it. This Wronged One hath, in most of His Tablets, made mention of His Majesty and hath beseeched from God--glorified be His mention--justice for him and sought fairness on his behalf. We beseech the Most High at this moment to illumine him with the light of justice which shall endure as long as the Kingdom of God, the Mighty, the Wondrous, shall endure.
Pray for him and beseech God for aid and assistance, that He may ever confirm him in justice and fairness, and make the oppressors captive to eternal abasement and failure.
Arise to help the Cause of God, then walk in the ways of justice and shun the paths of the oppressors.
Then command the people to justice and piety and forbid them from transgression and indecency.
Through them the lights of Thy justice have shone forth from the horizon, through them the breezes of Thy generosity have been wafted throughout the realms of possibility, through them Thou hast protected Thy servants from the evil of the rebellious ones, through them Thou hast caused Thy bondsmen to dwell in the cradle of security.
They are like unto mere children, and our Lord is the Educator of the world. If We but willed, we could have seized them with a single word from Us, yet the mercy of the Lord, the Almighty, the All-Glorious, the All-Powerful, supersedes His wrath.
By God! He dealeth with grace after justice hath appeared through this straight Balance.
Say: Contend not with anyone, nor deny any soul's rights. Consider ye the justice of God and His mercy which encompasseth the worlds.
We beseech God, exalted be He, to reward them for their deeds in this world and the next and to decree for them the recompense of attaining His presence. Verily He is the Forgiving, the Generous.
When Thou bestowest favor there is intimacy, and when Thou showest justice there is trepidation. Thou art the Merciful, the Generous, and the Kind.
O my Lord, my Hope, the Ultimate Goal of my aspirations and the End of my desires! I beseech Thee by the sovereignty of Thy forgiveness which encompasses all created things, and by the vastness of the ocean of Thy pardon wherein are immersed all sinners among contingent beings, and by the outpourings of Thy clemency which have flooded all creation, to enfold this servant in the beauty of Thy pardon, to strengthen him with the hosts of Thy forgiveness, to treat him according to Thy grace and not according to Thy justice, and to fulfill Thy promise regarding Thy servant.
Continue exploring
For thought and discussion
Questions to carry forward
- What does the distinction between a wage and a gift clarify, and where does it leave questions open?
- How can personal forgiveness coexist with the protection of people harmed by wrongdoing?
- What could distinguish accountability aimed at transformation from revenge?
- How do the passages concerning rulers and professionals connect power with responsibility?
- What does Micah’s inclusion of humility add to the practice of justice and mercy?
- Where might seeking mercy for oneself enlarge one’s capacity to act fairly toward others?