If there should not be decomposition, composition would not be. For instance, take several things. Until the different things are separately decomposed the composition and union is impossible. For example, if you wish the dust and stone and wood to be mixed perfectly with each other, it is impossible unless each be decomposed into its salts; when we have dissolved them then we can compose them. For instance, in a pharmacy they first dissolve the medicines, then bring them together and then they give a firm union. Before dissolution composition is impossible.
Composition and decomposition: the changing forms of life
composition and decomposition
Editorial introduction
Nothing is ever simply destroyed. When a body is lost, ‘Abdu’l-Bahá teaches, its elements are not annihilated but released, and only because they are released can they enter new compositions: the dust of one form becomes the leaf, the animal, the human frame of another. Life, in this account, is composition and death is decomposition, and the pain of dying is the pain of leaving a form to which one had grown accustomed. Yet the elements that scatter are not the person. Against the composite and perishable body stands a spirit that is single and indivisible, and the very fact that every composition eventually dissolves becomes an argument: a joining that was neither accidental nor compelled by the elements themselves must have been willed. Socrates, in the Phaedo, asks much the same question about what is liable to dissolution and what is not [1]. The theme reaches beyond physics. Attraction and cohesion are what give a flower or a stone its existence, and discord is what ends it, so the same law is read into human fellowship, where separation is a kind of death. From here the inquiry opens into life and death, the law of transformation and change, corruption and renewal, and the old insight that things are known by their opposites.
Selected passages
The law of composition and decomposition, amalgamation and dissolution, construction and destruction, protection and danger are two basal principles of creation. An organism - whether living or inanimate - must be decomposed at a stated time so that through its scattered atoms or elements other organisms may be composed and created. Creation therefore is based upon the activity of these two fundamental laws.
His death, therefore, consists of the dispersion of these elements. The elements, though, remain and do not disappear. In this case, life consists of composition and death consists of dispersion and the transition of elements from one state to another.
The body is composed of so many elements and each element in its dissolution must return to its original constituent substance.
A mineral compared to us may be said to be non-existent, but in its own sphere it lives. When we die our bodies return to the mineral and vegetable world. This example shows the inter-relationship of the different kingdoms which is erroneously called annihilation.
All these things up to this point are a contingent reality, and are not a divine reality. But a contingent reality which is perpetuated by the fullness of existence, will then suffer no corruption, and will thus become a divine reality, for the accidental reality is only distinguished from the existent reality by its subjection to corruption. For transformation is an essential necessity to ever contingent reality, and this is what the mature wisdom has deemed advisable.
Consider likewise creation and dissolution, existence and non-existence. Every created thing is composed of diverse and multiple elements, and existence itself is contingent upon composition. That is, when through divine creation a combination occurs among simple elements, from each combination a being takes form. All existence follows this pattern. When disorder arises in that composition and dissolution occurs and the elements separate, that being ceases to exist. In other words, the annihilation of anything means the decomposition and separation of its elements.
Composition is the means and cause of life and decomposition is the cause of death. Now several elements are composed and united and form this flower, and so several elements are composed and the body is formed, and so with everything. … For instance, in this wood there are molecules. These molecules are gathered together and composed, then wood will be found. All substance gets its life from unification and composition and when separation takes place among these molecules, death is certain.
This world is the plane of creation and disintegration. The process never stops: On one side it creates new people, and on the other it destroys what she has created.
Because it is decreed by God that every plant that grows must wither, all flourishing vegetation must fade away, every combination must disperse and all compositions must disintegrate. These are the necessary consequences of that universal law and of all relationships and is interpreted as divine decree.
When elements are attracted, something is composed, and when these same elements are repelled, that form is decomposed. As by the will of God the power of composition exists, so, also by will of God the power of decomposition exists.
When we study phenomena, with the investigation of truth as our object, we discover that the law of conservation of energy is a reality; that the elemental realities are ever existent, and that phenomena are the compositions thereof; that each phenomenon or existent being is composed of certain elements, this being a scientific fact that can be verified by natural philosophy; that every single molecule is composed of certain atoms; that the ion is indestructible and subject to coursing and journeyings throughout interminable space.
Take this noble offspring, which is this prepared earth that has come into being from sulfuric fire and mercurial water, and mix it with a portion of dissolved mercury which is its essence and reality and is from its elemental realm. Place it in a gentle, moderate fire until some of that prepared earth is dissolved.
Just as there has been a process of composition, there is also of necessity a process of decomposition.
For every organic and inorganic matter there are two ways of growth - longitudinal and horizontal. When mineral substances are decomposed and then those decomposed atoms go into the makeup of other mineral organisms - this is called longitudinal growth; but when those decomposed mineral matters go into the composition of vegetable life - it is called horizontal growth.
He answered: "These contingent elements are nothing but the composition of various single atoms. The individual atoms appear from time to time in various forms. Therefore composition is the sign of life, and decomposition is the sign of mortality. With this principle well established, where can you prove the necessity for the existence of a creator? There is a natural law which impels the various single atoms to come together involuntarily and to form a composite object.
When you ask them "Who is the Creator of the world? What is your opinion in the matter?" They will answer: "It is quite plain and evident that there are various kinds of elements, and by being composed a being is formed."
We must say, "You are right, it seems to be so, but we have heard something else, some philosophers and learned men told us as follows: 'When we look carefully at objects and things we can comprehend and understand that by the composition of some elements something is formed; this is quite evident. But there are three kinds of composition.
One is accomplished by force; for instance, fire attracts water, this is made through force - that is, the elements attract each other; when they come together they form an object. This kind of composition is called innate or natural attraction, made by force.
The second kind of composition is said to be done by chance, for instance, it rained by chance, the sun cast its rays by chance; therefore, vegetables grow.
The third is a composition made by will, by aim;--for instance,--A doctor gives a medicine which is composed of various elements, compounded by his will; knowing the ingredients of the drugs he compounds them by will.'
We must look and see very carefully that we understand whether the things or objects of the world are formed through the power of attraction made by force; if it is so, then there should not be the decomposition, because the elements attracted by the other must remain together everlastingly; corruption must not take place; some realize that there are both composition and decomposition.
As to the second, which was by chance,--this is also not perfect, but completely invalid. How can there be movement without a mover?
As to the third, that all objects in the world are made or formed by will. Then, there should be a Creator for everything, for instance, to place the eye in its own place, the ear in its proper place, etc. Such a power creates, gives life to man, and works through His will. We call this will, GOD! All the prophets believed in such a Great Being."
On the other hand those who are informed of divine philosophy answer in the following terms: Composition is of three kinds.
1. Accidental composition.
2. Involuntary composition.
3. Voluntary composition.
There is no fourth kind of composition.
… While we observe that after each composite organism, there is a process of decomposition we learn that the composition of the organisms of life is neither accidental nor involuntary. Then what have we as a form of composition? It is the third, that is the voluntary composition. And that means that the infinite forms of organisms are composed through a superior will, the eternal will, the will of the living and self-subsistent Lord.
This is a rational proof, that the Will of the creator is effected through the process of composition.
Moreover, every composition of elements must eventually become decomposed, and this decomposition is inevitable. These sicknesses and ailments are the causes of dissolution. Otherwise the bodily composition of man would be preserved and never cease to exist.
The body of man is the result of the composition of the elements and these elements are constantly at war with each other. They wage such a bitter war on each other that at last both sides come to defeat and disintegration.
This physical body is accidental and the inherent quality of every accidental composition is decomposition. For example, the inherent quality of the house demands that someday it be destroyed. It cannot stand forever. The inherent attribute of this body requires the ultimate return of each element to its origin, after its disintegration. Neither through the power of thought nor prayer can this physical, material body become permanent.
This human nature is composed of the elements. And no doubt for all the material or elemental composition there is a disintegration. But it is not composed of one element. Over 17 elements have gone into the composition of matter. Being composed of divergent elements, it is necessarily exposed or subjected to decomposition; becomes disintegrated. But the ideal nature, being an indestructible Spirit, and being one and unique in nature, being absolute radiance, the sublimity of the human nature is eternal and permanent, and it is not to be subject to disintegration.
Therefore it is most evident that composition or organization and union are perpetuation of species. When the composition, or rather, compound is subjected to a flaw in the agreement (of the elements) separation and dissolution result. Therefore, it is plain and evident, that agreement and union among men are productive of life results. Every movement which aims at separation, causes disagreement and produces dissension amongst men, is to be condemned and rejected.
All of these beings receive their existence through the collection of different members, ingredients and simple particles. From each composition a being is produced, therefore an infinite number of beings exist.
For instance, this flower is composed form the composition of different elements, and the gathering of simple particles. This is called a being; and when among these elements decomposition occurs, these ingredients separate, death slips in, and it is annihilated. Hence it is evident that composition and gathering cause life, and decomposition and disunion cause death. Thus every matter which leads to unity and gathering confers life, and that which causes separation is the means of death.
Further quotations · supplied wording and references
In this endless Universe everything has a beginning and an end. Some things end quickly and some last a long time, but it is sure that they will end at some time. It is impossible that a composed thing should not be decomposed.
Continue exploring
For thought and discussion
Questions to carry forward
- How can decomposition be both a loss and a condition for new forms of life?
- What distinctions do the passages make between a body, its elements, and the spirit?
- How do the arguments from composition toward divine will work, and what assumptions do they ask a reader to consider?
- What can Plato’s distinction between composite and uncompounded things clarify, and where do the two presentations differ?
- What does the analogy between physical cohesion and social unity illuminate, and where might it cease to be helpful?
- How might these readings deepen a conversation about grief, transformation, and the relationships that sustain a community?