Partial InventoryBROWSER

Necessary and contingent being

necessary and possible being

13 selections · 12 reading entries · Current subject view ↗

Editorial introduction

Nobody chooses to fall asleep, and nobody escapes death; ‘Abdu’l-Bahá begins from such plain compulsions to show that the whole contingent world lives under a law it did not make. Everything we meet is dependent, limited, divisible, caused, and that dependence points to a reality that is none of these things: the Necessary Being, self-sufficient and without beginning, whose perfection is the measure of our imperfection. The vocabulary gets precise along the way. The existence we can conceive in the mind is itself only an accident of things, not that real Existence through which all things are realized; a chair is originated because it has a cause, which is a different matter from having begun at some moment in time; and to call creation nothing beside God is to speak relatively, for even a stone has being, and created things are not parts of God but realities He has made. Aquinas, arguing from the possible to the necessary, follows a path that can be walked step by step beside these claims [1]. The road leads on to existence and nonexistence, to preexistence and eternity, and to the relation of essence to substance and form.

Selected passages

Back to subjectQuestions for reflection ↓Preparing fonts…
01

It is certain that the entire contingent world is subject to an order and a law which it can never disobey. Even man is forced to submit to death, sleep, and other conditions-that is, in certain matters he is compelled, and this very compulsion implies the existence of One Who is All-Compelling. So long as the contingent world is characterized by dependency, and so long as this dependency is one of its essential requirements, there must be One Who in His own Essence is independent of all things.

(‘Abdu’l-Bahá, Chapter 2, Proofs and Evidences of the Existence of God, 1904-Jun ca. -- AB00815)
02

O divine friends! The reality of contingent existence is pure imperfection, while the essence of necessity is absolute perfection. That is, imperfection is inherent in the essential requirements of contingent things, while perfection is the reality and essence of the Lord of Names and Attributes.

(‘Abdu’l-Bahá, to Baha'is of Kushkbagh -- AB02999)
03

Were the Essence the Simple Reality for multiplicities, nothing would exist save His own manifestation, yet intuition testifies to the falsity of this through the limitations of creation, their weakness, and their need for the Bountiful Source.

(The Báb, Tablet to Mirza Sa'id Ardistani on Basitatu'l-Haqiqah, qadim wa hadith, to Mirza Sa'id Ardistani -- BB00064)
04

But the truly learned among the Theosophists and Sufis have concluded, after deep consideration of this matter, that there are two kinds of existence. One kind is this common existence which is conceived by the mind of man. This existence is originated and is an accident among others, whereas the realities of things are the substances. But what is meant by unity of existence is not this commonly perceived existence, but that real Existence which is sanctified and exalted above all expression, an Existence through which all things are realized. This Existence is one; it is that One through which all things---such as matter, energy, and that common existence which is conceived by the human mind---have come to exist.

(‘Abdu’l-Bahá, Chapter 82, The Unity of Existence, 1906-Dec-12 -- AB00062)
05

Who is there, O my Lord, that, when Thou revealest the first glimmerings of the signs of Thy transcendent sovereignty and might, hath the power to claim for himself any existence whatever? Existence itself is as nothing when brought face to face with the mighty and manifold wonders of Thine incomparable Self.

(Bahá’u’lláh, 1290 [1873] or earlier -- BH03585)
06

Contingent existence is pure imperfection and sheer nothingness - grant a gleam and effusion from the perfection of the Necessary Being and absolute existence.

(‘Abdu’l-Bahá, 1900 or <, to Ustad Ghulam-Husayn et al -- AB05302)
07

Essential pre-existence is an existence which is not preceded by a cause; essential origination is preceded by a cause. Temporal pre-existence has no beginning; temporal origination has both a beginning and an end. For the existence of each and every thing depends upon four causes: the efficient cause, the material cause, the formal cause and the final cause. So this chair has a creator who is a carpenter, a matter which is wood, a form which is that of a chair, and a purpose which is to serve as a seat. Therefore, this chair is essentially originated, for it is preceded by, and its existence is conditioned upon, a cause.

(‘Abdu’l-Bahá, Chapter 80, True Pre-existence, 1904-Jun ca. -- AB00839)
08

Descent, division, transmission and transmigration in the stations of life are the conditions of the contingent beings, but the Eternal Reality is wholly beyond and above these conditions; for when you behold that a being is subject to division, descent and disintegration, this is a proof, of the contingency and impermanency of that being. The Ancient, the Ever-living, and the Omniscient Lord, who is above the comprehension of humanity and is qualified with self-existent perfections, will never descend to the stations of life, and will not be divided so that every man may become an atom or a part of Him.

(‘Abdu’l-Bahá, 1911-May-24, to James B Thornton Chase -- AB00249)
09

Existence is of two kinds: One is the existence of the True One (God) which is sanctified above the comprehension of creation. He is the Unknowable Invisible. He is not preceded by any cause, but rather is the Creator of the Cause of causes. He is Ancient without beginning and absolutely Self-Sufficient. The second existence is that of creation. It is a general existence which is a mental concept that human reason can comprehend. This existence is originated, dependent, preceded by cause, and contingent. Therefore, the contingent cannot become ancient, and the ancient cannot become contingent. Creation cannot become Creator, and the Creator cannot become creation. The transformation of essence is impossible in the realm of existence.

(‘Abdu’l-Bahá, 1919-Jul-20, to John Wolcott -- AB01382)
10

And regarding proof for the temporal eternity of contingent beings in this transient world - briefly, divine sovereignty is eternal, and the existence of beings is from the eternal effulgences of the Sun of Reality. One cannot imagine the sun without rays. All divine names and attributes are eternal, and their requirements are also eternal. This is a brief answer - reflect upon it to derive detailed meanings, as there is no opportunity for elaboration.

(‘Abdu’l-Bahá, 1904 ca., to Mulla Yusuf-i-Nakhai (Khusif) -- AB00695)

Further quotations · supplied wording and references

11

Existence (vujud) is of two kinds: conceptual ('ilmi) and material ('ayni). Prior to being embodied in material forms, all created things existed on a conceptual plane, that is to say they were entities within the knowledge of God. They subsequently found material existence and became visible in the external world. Conceptual existence hath no impact on the eye; it can only be affected by material reality.

(Provisional translation, AB00954)

Catalogue reference: AB00954 · passage alignment is approximate; supplied wording retained.

12

Compared to God nothing has existence but this does not mean that even stones do not have being. It is speaking relatively. Moreover, God reveals Himself in all things in the sense that He is the source of their being and the Cause of their existence. Without Him all things will shrink down into nothing. This however does not mean that all things are parts of God as the pantheist believes. The pantheist says that only God exists, objects are mere modes of His attributes. Baha'u'llah however says that objects have a separate reality that is created by God.

LG#1583 (26 Oct. 1932 on behalf of Shoghi Effendi)

Supplied quotation · catalogue passage not verified

Continue exploring

For thought and discussion

Questions to carry forward

  1. Which experiences of dependence make the distinction between necessary and contingent being intelligible, and what further argument does it require?
  2. How is dependence on a cause different from having a beginning at a particular time?
  3. What does it mean to call created existence relative without dismissing the world as unreal?
  4. How might the philosophical argument and the prayers affect one another when read together?
About this collection

A new window onto the Bahá'í Writings.

This site offers several different ways of exploring the original texts and translations attributed to the Central Figures of the Bahá'í Faith -- the Báb, Bahá’u’lláh, and ‘Abdu’l-Bahá -- that are accessible in the public domain. It is a personal project and accuracy is not guaranteed; please visit the official website at https://www.bahai.org/library for authenticated texts.

Catalog view

Search by word or phrase (in quotation marks) for a specific text, or use the menu at left to narrow your search by date, recipient, catalog ID, publications, related musical compositions, and more. View a text in the original Arabic/Persian, in English translation, or side by side where available. Authorized translations are displayed in blue, provisional in black.

Volume view

The 29,000+ texts have been arranged in approximate chronological order and provisionally grouped into 192 volumes for a more traditional reading experience. Each volume has its own introduction and is followed by a study guide. The volumes can be read in-browser or downloaded to pdf.

Subject view

Browse by subject by searching for a category in the left-hand panel, or use the knowledge graph in the center panel to navigate to related subjects. The 659 subjects and their relationships are human-generated; the brief subject summaries are AI-generated. Relevant passages touching on each subject -- some human generated and some selected with the help of AI and lightly vetted -- appear below the knowledge graph. These passages can be downloaded to PDF for offline reading.

Study guides

The passages compiled under each subject have been further condensed and re-ordered to facilitate an introductory thematic study of the texts. At the end of each guide is a set of open-ended questions and hyperlinks to adjacent subjects.

About the sources

Texts and metadata are derived from the Partial Inventory project (version 6.01), an open-source, individual initiative not affiliated with Bahá'í institutions. For a summary of documents and presentations about this rapidly evolving project see this page. The project bibliography and key to source codes, with a summary of the source schema and color assignments, can be downloaded here.

To interact with this collection via LLM, see the separate Gemini Notebook instances in English and Persian/Arabic

This is a static collection browser. It has no accounts, does not track or save your activity, and runs entirely on your device.

Project repository ↗